I was really hoping that the RSS comments feed bug would get fixed in version 1.4.4.1b, but I guess not.

If I go to index?rss=comments&type=gallery it will only show one comment in the feed and that is from 2009. But if I login, it will then show all of the newest ones.

Any ideas??

I will take a look. Please check that your albums/images or their parents are really published and not protected. Otherwise this behaviour would be correct.
Also make sure you cleared the rss cache.

I have checked all that. And it still does it.

Please open a ticket.