Hi trisweb,
I can set things back the way they were and post a link tomorrow or Tuesday, if you want. (I'd need to change the htaccess and such to post a public password here.) The "dramatically degraded" was under the original settings in my 2nd post.
Here's what the settings are now.
Image quality 85
Image size 600
I realized changing the image size to match the size of the pictures I already uploaded was easier

. For the re-sized images the quality between the bread crumbs and the image page is the same now. It's sort of hard to tell with the full size images if the bread crumb page and the full size image is very different, so that's a big improvement too. But with this monitor it's hard to tell, and I have someone who will look at the full sizes images I posted today with a better monitor (but dial up) tomorrow.
I will continue to post back if changing those settings fixed the blurriness. I think that pre-caching and making the image size 600 improved speed for me, but the acid test will be combining dial-up with Vista tomorrow.
Thank you!